“And Also Upon the Israel of God”

Why Galatians 6:16 Does Not Teach Replacement Theology

Just a reminder, before we proceed with this topic, that you can access and read all of my previous articles by clicking on this link: www.fromstuart.com/archive

Introduction

Galatians 6:16 is often cited as proof that the Church has replaced Israel. But when the verse is read carefully—especially in its grammatical and historical context—it points to a different conclusion: Paul is blessing two groups, not redefining one.

Does Galatians 6:16 Teach That the Church Replaced Israel?

Short answer:
No. When read carefully, Galatians 6:16 does not redefine Israel as the Church. Instead, Paul appears to bless two groups—Gentile believers and believing Jews.

The Whole Debate Comes Down to One Word

At the center of Galatians 6:16 is a small Greek word:

kai
Usually translated:

• and

• also

The verse reads:

“Peace and mercy be upon those who follow this rule, and also upon the Israel of God.”

The Key Question

Does kai mean:

• “and also” → two groups
  OR

• “that is” / “even” → one group renamed

Most Natural Meaning: Two Groups

Paul keeps the second kai, which strongly suggests addition, not redefinition.

That means:

• First group → Gentile believers who follow the rule of faith

• Second group → Jewish believers who follow the rule of faith = “the Israel of God”

Paul’s Normal Use of “Israel”

Across the New Testament:

• Israel appears 70+ times

• It always refers to ethnic Israel

• It never refers to the Church

Why This Matters

If Galatians 6:16 suddenly changed the meaning of “Israel,” it would be:

• A major shift

• With no clear explanation

The simpler explanation:

“Israel” still means Jewish people—specifically Jewish believers.

The Context of Galatians: Two Groups, One Gospel

Galatians was written to Gentile believers who were being pressured to follow the Law of Moses by a group called “Judaizers.”

They were…

• Jews who had some sort of identification with Christ

• Who insisted that Gentile Christians must keep the Mosaic Law

• Especially:

  • Circumcision

  • Dietary laws

  • Observance of Jewish festivals

• Who taught that faith in Christ alone was not enough

Their teaching can be summarized as:

Faith in Jesus + keeping the Law of Moses = Salvation

This is what the Apostle Paul strongly opposed.

Paul summarizes the gospel rule in Galatians 6:15:

“Neither circumcision nor uncircumcision means anything, but a new creation.”

That rule—salvation by grace alone through faith alone in Jesus alone—is the basis for verse 16.

The Two Groups Paul Blesses

Group 1

“Those who follow this rule”

Refers to:

• Gentile believers

• Gentiles rejecting legalism

• Gentiles trusting in Christ alone

Group 2

“The Israel of God”

Refers to:

• Jewish believers

• Jews rejecting legalism

• Jews trusting in Christ alone

Paul is not redefining Israel.
He is distinguishing believing Jews from unbelieving Judaizers.

Why Replacement Theology Struggles Here

To read Galatians 6:16 as teaching that the Church replaces Israel requires:

• Ignoring Paul’s normal use of “Israel”

• Giving kai an unusual meaning

• Removing distinctions Paul regularly maintains

The Big Picture: What Paul Is Really Saying

Galatians 6:16 teaches:

Peace and mercy belong to all who follow the gospel rule of justification by faith alone—

• Gentile believers

• And also Jewish believers (“the Israel of God”)

Paul is:

• Not redefining Israel

• Not replacing Israel

• But blessing both groups

Conclusion

Rather than redefining Israel, Paul affirms God’s peace upon all believers—both Gentile followers of Christ and the believing remnant within Israel.

Peace to you, who have embraced the Gospel of peace, through faith in Jesus, the Prince of Peace.

-Stuart